For me the old is good how did ;the earth is stronger tan lightning dont forget the earth have a conductivity too and i think its not the only reason of why the lighntning is beter tan the earth and if you choose the new one it will break the balence of the elements at the end it will not be realistic because earth is not stronger tan lightning but is stronger tan water if the enemy ninja lunch a water bullet or a water wave you just have to do a earth wall,shield to protect you the water cant pass the wall and you can do a counter atack with earth spike or a jutsu like that so the older one is the best because all the element are stronger against another one and for the good reason. fire:stronger tan wind because it make the fire bigger Wind:is stronger tan lightning because you can cut through lightning and thing like that because its the only element who can counter it. Lightning:is stronger tan earth because of its conductivity and probably because the electricity can disrupt the molecules who is at solid form when you do a earth wall or something like that with the earth element and make it more soft and easy to pass through with a chidori something like that but for this second argument im not so sure. Earth:is stronger tan water because it can block the waters jutsu and others things like that. Water:is stronger tan fire because it can extinguish the fire. its good like that. the others things if i can call it the *element factor tab* is the fact that lightning have conductivity on waters too and water at long term win on earth and a water bullet with compressed water can probably blow up a earth wall but only if the water is compressed at a very good percentage it depend on the training and on the elemental knowledge because a compressed water bullet for exemple at 500 elemental control,knowledge cant blow up earth wall of a ninja who have 1000 element control and knowledge because the wall is too strong if a ninja have 1500 water knowledge he can compress his water bullet at a beter percentage than a ninja with 1000 element control and knowledge of his earth element and blow up his wall same thing with the others elements and its the base if you want to do a naruto game you need things like elemental control,knowledge for the players to be stronger and learn a jutsu who need 100,200,500,1000 elemental knowledge of one of the five elements,or special element and things like that to learn it. at the end i think its a good idea to go with the old elemental tab and deal with the *element factor tab* later with the special factor who don't just act on one element but 2 or 3 like conductivity and other things like that. system of jutsu learning,,control,knowledge.need to be done too about how we will learn our jutsu and thing like that im sure you will do it when one of the 2 element tab will be choose the old one or the new one for me i thik the old one is the best.